DETROIT LAKES, Minn. - The First Lutheran Church in Detroit Lakes has started the process of replacing Pastor John Simonson and his wife, Rachel, also a pastor at First Lutheran, following his resignation after criminal charges were filed against him.

John Simonson joined First Lutheran in Detroit Lakes as an associate pastor in 2015, after three years at his first ministry in Killdeer, N.D. He resigned from First Lutheran in late March.

Simonson, 38, was accused of stealing liquor from the Detroit Lakes municipal liquor store and scratching a person's vehicle with a metal object after an altercation with a woman at the liquor store on Dec. 20.

He was charged in Becker County District Court with gross misdemeanor third-degree criminal damage to property, and misdemeanor theft.

According to court records and the police incident report, about 9 p.m. on Dec. 20 Simonson allegedly had a verbal altercation with a Frazee woman at Lakes Liquor. Following the altercation, he allegedly used a metal object to scrape or "key" her brown 2014 Buick Enclave.

Newsletter signup for email alerts

Simonson replaced longtime Pastor Dave Peterson when Peterson retired in late 2017.

"We're looking for an interim pastor now," said Susie Reitmeier, business manager at First Lutheran. "That's how the Lutheran Church does it."

Peterson previously said, "ELCA protocol says, when a pastor leaves, they leave." So he won't be serving as interim pastor.

Video footage of the parking lot showed Simonson using a metal object to make a downward scratch near the passenger side front and rear door. He made a statement admitting to damaging the victim's vehicle. The cost of repair was listed as just over $593. An affidavit for restitution was served Jan. 29.

Video footage from inside the liquor store allegedly shows Simonson approach a display of "shooters" or mini bottles of alcohol, take an unknown number of shooters, place them in his pocket, and continue to shop. He then left the store without paying for the merchandise in his pocket.

His case is set for an omnibus hearing May 6 before Becker County District Judge Peter Irvine.